Philosophyspeaking topic
Newcomb's paradox: a being that predicts the future almost perfectly sets out two boxes. Take only the closed box and it is full; take both and it is empty. Logic says take both boxes, so why does intuition keep telling us to take just one?
— Newcomb's paradox
practice with this topic
Set the timer (5-30 min), take 20 seconds of prep if you like, start talking. Jot your thoughts onto the sticky-note board.
similar topics
- Every night when you fall asleep your consciousness switches off completely, and every morning it comes back. Is the person who wakes up really the one who fell asleep, or a brand new consciousness that inherited their memories? What exactly separates sleep from death?
- The body is the tomb of the soul.
- The surprise execution paradox: a prisoner is told he will be hanged one day next week, but he will never know which day in advance. By pure logic he proves that no day is possible, and is then hanged, completely surprised, on Wednesday. Where did the reasoning go wrong?
- Thomson's violinist: you wake up with a famous violinist plugged into your body, and only nine months of your life can keep him alive. Does someone's survival give them a right to use your body?
- The ethics of care: should morality be grounded in abstract rules, or in concrete relationships and compassion? Could the bonds we feel for one another explain morality better than the scales of justice?