Sciencespeaking topic
Counterfactual causation: saying X caused it really means if X hadn't happened, this wouldn't have either. Can we ever know an alternative that never occurred as well as we know the past?
— the counterfactual theory of causation
practice with this topic
Set the timer (5-30 min), take 20 seconds of prep if you like, start talking. Jot your thoughts onto the sticky-note board.
similar topics
- Preregistration: a researcher announces the hypothesis and analysis plan before collecting any data. Why does putting a prediction in writing beforehand change honesty so much?
- Insect populations are collapsing globally and almost nobody is talking about it. Why do some environmental crises capture attention while others stay invisible?
- If you watch someone fall into a black hole from the outside, you never see them fall in; they seem frozen at the edge forever. But for the person falling, it's all over in an instant. The same event, utterly different for two people. Which one 'really' happened?
- An avalanche begins without a single snowflake deciding to fall; the system quietly tenses, then a tiny touch triggers everything. Why do great collapses always erupt at the moment things seem calmest?
- Entangle two particles and carry them to opposite ends of the galaxy, and the instant you measure one, the other is affected at once. No signal passes between them. Does the universe sometimes not care about distance at all?